top of page
Search
NFL Fantasy Football – Loves and Hates From Each Round

NFL Fantasy Football – Loves and Hates From Each Round

Sam Barrett
Aug 16, 2024
5 min read

It's that time of year where NFL fantasy drafts are right around the corner. And its important to know which players you should be drafting and which players you should be avoiding. In the latest episode of the Four Down Territory podcast, we looked at players we love and hate from each of the first 9 rounds of fantasy drafts. You can find the full episode at the bottom of this article. But for the first 3 rounds – here's a list of some of the players we covered:


Round 1

Love – Amon-Ra St.Brown

To put it simply, the best player going in the first round of fantasy drafts this year is plain and simple. Amon-Ra brings three main reasons for success: a high floor/ceiling, a stable offence, and a reasonable price. It's the perfect mix to ensure you're getting what you need out of your first round pick. So let's go through these three reasons...


Last season, there were only two games in which Amon-Ra scored less than 16 points (PPR). And he scored 20+ points in nine outings last year, with three 30+ point games. He was one of the best "set and forget" players in lineups every week. If you had Amon Ra on your team, you knew you were practically guaranteed production every week, with an average of over 10 targets per game. This combination of floor and ceiling makes him as reliable as it comes, with a guarantee to give you league winning upside. This gives him the edge on some of the first round targets around him.


The Detroit offense is incredibly fantasy friendly this year. They were one of the highest scoring units in the league last year, with a fantastic rushing and passing game, which lead to many of their key players generating notable fantasy output. And this year expects to be no different, which hugely benefits Amon-Ra St. Brown. The offensive line is poised to be a top 5 unit, in both run blocking and pass protection. Jared Goff enjoyed a strong, consistent year last season, with an incredibly strange key factor: Jared Goff plays best in a dome. Weirdly enough, Goff seemed to struggle as a passer playing in outdoor stadiums where inclement weather had an effect on passing games (namely in a week 7 loss @ the Ravens). Luckily for Detroit fans this year, the Lions play 14 games this season in dome stadiums. It seems like it should be negligible, but these are the small factors that can make all the difference between wins and losses in fantasy football.


And finally, Amon-Ra comes at a very reasonable price. Most sites have his ADP (Average Draft Position) at around pick 6-10. A mid first round pick for a guy that could arguably be the best player in fantasy football by the end of this season? That seems like a great price to pay.


Hate – Jahmyr Gibbs

Let me first preface by saying this: there isn't really a first round pick worthy of hating. If you're spending a first round pick on someone, its likely that they'll produce, outside of some unexpected circumstances (injury etc.)


But if I was forced to pick someone, it would be Jahmyr Gibbs. Don't get me wrong, we fully expect Gibbs to have a great campaign this season. But his consistency might not be as guaranteed as expected due to one factor.


David Montgomery.


The Detroit backfield remains a two-headed beast. Monty is the power back. For short yardage situations, the Lions will often opt to use Montgomery. This means that Monty is more likely to see the goal line carries that will produce rushing touchdowns. If David Montgomery is stealing touchdown opportunities from Gibbs, it limits his ceiling. And for the price you have to pay for Gibbs, I'd rather use a much later round pick on Montgomery, same as last year.


Round 2:

Love – Jonathan Taylor

The second round is loaded with what ifs. Guys like Drake London and Davante Adams could all produce at colossal levels. But there's uncertainties to their production. Jonathan Taylor however, feels like a sure bet for success. The Colts possess a great run blocking offensive line, which should enable Taylor to see lots of opportunities for breaking runs of 10+ yards. And while some see the presence of Anthony Richardson as a threat to Taylor's volume, which is true, there's a good chance it leads to his touches being more valuable. Defences will have to respect Richardson's rushing ability, which could allow Taylor find more open running lanes. This will be especially true around the goal line, where teams could key in on AR5, leaving Taylor more room to run.


Additionally, if you look at the Colts RB room, there isn't a single other RB on that roster that should take meaningful touches away from Taylor, aside from some passing situations that could favour Trey Sermon or Tyler Goodson. But other than that, expect Taylor to be a heavy feature in this Colts offense.


Hate – Josh Allen

Year after year Josh Allen puts up numbers that make him one of the top quarterbacks in fantasy football. So why should you avoid him this year? It's simply a matter of price. Josh Allen's ADP is currently in the second half of round 2, which for me is too high a price to pay for a quarterback given how good the other players are in that range.


The Bills offense has lost many key pieces over the offseason. Stefon Diggs and Gabe Davis leave the WR room, and important players on the offensive line including centre Mitch Morse. Josh Allen is likely to find himself playing a lot of hero ball next year, where he'll have to make plays by himself. And that recipe is not always great for fantasy output.


If you find Allen falling to the mid 3rd round and beyond, smash draft. But any higher than that, I'm not a fan.


Round 3:

Love – Cooper Kupp

It was only 2021 when Cooper Kupp set the league on fire with a triple crown season of 145 receptions, 1,947 yards and 16 receiving touchdowns. Since then, Kupp has struggled with injuries which have prevented him from producing at a high level consistently. But this year, he comes in completely healthy. And with Puka Nacua nursing a knee injury, Kupp will spend the preseason being Stafford's favourite target, and this connection should continue into the season.


Sean McVay's offense will again be a top system in the league that should give Kupp plenty of opportunities to produce fantasy points. And for the price of a 3rd round pick? It's an easy choice for me.


Hate – Sam LaPorta

This uses similar logic to why we're avoiding Josh Allen in the 2nd round. The 3rd round is absolutely stacked with talent, and I'm not a fan of LaPorta at this price. He's the second passing option in a run first offense, and while I don't doubt that he'll put up good numbers this year, I'd prefer to take a shot at someone like Nico Collins or Isiah Pacheco.


Listen to our episode to for more depth on these selections, and for our choices in round 4-9, followed by players to target/avoid in rounds 10 and beyond. You can find it below.


Happy drafting!



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page